AE Vol. 29, no. 3

Contents of Volume 29, Number 3
August 2002
articles
497 people of the chisel: apprenticeship, youth, and elites in Oku (Cameroon)
Nicolas Argenti
 

In this article, I explore the ways in which Oku carvers negotiate their relation to the palace hierarchy and to the nation-state by means of the master–apprentice relationship. I describe the palace hierarchy’s incorporation of the procreational powers of apprenticed carvers and examine a separate group of nonapprenticed carvers and the alternative network of new-elite patrons for whom they work. This case study leads to a deconstruction of the dichotomies pitting locality against the state, palatine against business elites, and tradition against modernity, suggesting that tradition may conceal social change and that modernist youth movements may conversely provide sources of historical continuity. [apprenticeship, youth, modernity, nationalism, elites, carving, hierarchy]

534 transgenderism, locality, and the Miss Galaxy beauty pageant in Tonga
Niko Besnier
 

The Miss Galaxy beauty pageant held annually in Nuku’alofa, the capital of Tonga, is, at first glance, a show of transgendered glamour, but it is equally a display of translocality. Through the performance of an exotic otherness (through costumes, names, dances, etc.), the socially marginalized contestants claim to define the local, in ways that may oppose the received order, in which the difference between locality and nonlocality is controlled by the privileged. The juxtaposition of gender transformation and translocality in the same event reinforces their stereotypical linking in the eyes of both transgendered and mainstream Tongans. For transgendered persons, this linking provides an escape route from local dynamics of social exclusion and poverty, but it also potentially offers mainstream persons a pretext to marginalize transgendered persons from their local groundings. Privileged transgendered persons are less vulnerable to these dynamics of exclusion and use tokens of translocality to assert their social standing vis-à-vis both underprivileged transgendered persons and society at large. [transgenderism, beauty pageants, locality, globalization, resistance, language use, Tonga]

 

567 the intimacies of power: rethinking violence and affinity in the Bolivian Andes
Krista E. Van Vleet
 

In the Bolivian Andes although violence between spouses is more frequent, violence also erupts between women who are affines. By examining events of violence through the discourses and practices that sustain asymmetries of power among affines, I demonstrate that kinship and violence in the highland Andean region of Sullk’ata are shaped by multiple inequalities and embedded in, yet extend beyond, the domestic arena. Incorporating violence into an analysis of kinship further highlights the lived interactions of individuals rather than static structures of kinship. [gender, power, domestic violence, marriage, kinship, Andes, Latin America]

602 a tale of goddesses, money, and other terribly wonderful things: spirit possession, commodity fetishism, and the narrative of capitalism in Rajasthan, India
Jeffrey G. Snodgrass
 

In this article, I examine the spiritual possession of a young Indian woman—a member of a community of performers known as Bhats—by her husband’s lineage goddess. The events unfold in the Rajasthani town of Udaipur where Bhats now market traditional culture to tourists. Showing how this possession responds to my informants’ new exchange relations, I argue for the utility of the Marxist notion of "commodity fetishism." I contend, however, that Marxist accounts, because of their typically insistent condemnation of capitalist transformation, are not able to account fully for the Bhat experience of new money relations. I maintain, instead, that an analysis emphasizing multiple moral narratives more completely illuminates the Bhats’ complex encounter with the economic forms of modernity. I further suggest that discourse-based descriptions of spiritual possession also cannot do full justice to this woman’s case, which is as much a failure to communicate as a successfully articulated, if disguised, mode of communication. I thus argue for an appreciation of the way religious forms, and particularly spiritual possessions, represent a form of language and the failure of language, as well as a kind of story and the inability to narrate experience. Overall, I develop an analytical framework that draws out the representational implications of the notion of fetishism—which, according to Marx, describes a situation in which images (such as money), if compelling enough, eclipse their referents (labor)—and that might do more justice to the Bhats’, themselves praise singers, own sophisticated engagement with fictions. [India, spirit possession, religion, money, commodity fetishism, capitalism, narrative, discourse, Marxism, poststructuralism]

 

637 "don’t be lazy, don’t lie, don’t steal": community justice in the neoliberal Andes
Rudi Colloredo-Mansfeld
 

Two processes have reshaped many Latin American indigenous societies: the rise of native movements and the transnationalization of rural economies. Although the connections between these two processes remain sharply debated, both critics and defenders of indigenous movements assume that ethnic unity and economic differentiation must work against each other. I argue otherwise, demonstrating that the territorial consequences of economic change—due chiefly to migration, stratification, and consumerism—invigorate local indigenous politics even as they fragment cultural values. By examining community justice in Otavalo, Ecuador, I show how indigenous people create politically effective unities while they simultaneously produce hierarchical relationships among places and cultural orientations through their activism. [indigenous peoples, grassroots politics, economic change, community justice, Andes, Ecuador]

 

663 nationalism in hybrid spaces: the production of impurity out of purity
Viranjini Munasinghe
 

In this article, I reflect on the symbolic position assigned to Indo-Trinidadians within national narratives of homogenization in Trinidad. By contrasting the Trinidadian case to Western European modular forms, I explore how historical particularities of this New World region have resulted in novel and creative ways of imagining a national community—namely, by foregrounding impurity or hybridity—that run counter to master narratives of nationalism as these are cast in Western Europe. Trinidadians simultaneously celebrate hybridity (mixture) and their plural society, but, in the final instance, like all nationalist narratives, the Trinidadian narrative remains a logic of exclusion. [nationalism, homogenization, hybridity, creolization, postcolonial, Caribbean, Trinidad]

 

693 the politics of desire and disdain: Croatian identity between "home" and "homeland"
Daphne Winland
 

The collapse of communism in the former Yugoslavia has sparked an avalanche of personal and political questions for Croatians everywhere on the meaning of their history, traditions, and identity. This article analyzes the mutually constitutive relationships of diaspora Croatians and the focus of their desire: a free Croatia whose citizens participate in the "production" or "recovery" of the historic Croatian state. But, rather than inspiring unity, independence has created the conditions for the emergence and exacerbation of often fraught or equivocal relationships within and between these groups. The Croatian example challenges the inclination to juxtapose diaspora and homeland contexts and points to the need to investigate the struggles of their subjects to define their often tenuous yet increasingly intimate relationships within, across, and between borders. [Croatian independence, politics of desire and disdain, diaspora, identity, homeland]

 

book reviews
719 the price of death: the funeral industry in contemporary Japan (Suzuki)
  Katherine Rupp
720 the anthropology of love and anger: the aesthetics of conviviality in native Amazonia (Overing and Passes, eds.)
  Krista E. Van Vleet
722 the female circumcision controversy: an anthropological perspective (Gruenbaum)
  Julie Hastings
723 consuming grief: compassionate cannibalism in an Amazonian society (Conklin)
  Fernando Santos-Granero
724 protection of intellectual, biological and cultural property in Papua New Guinea (Whimp and Busse, eds.)
  Michael F. Brown
725 the invention of the passport: surveillance, citizenship and the state (Torpey)
  Sarah Lund
727 medicalizing ethnicity: the construction of Latino identity in a psychiatric setting (Santiago-Irizarry)
  Vincent Lyon-Callo
728 the karma of brown folk (Prashad)
  Susan Koshy
730 white love and other events in Filipino history (Rafael)
  Nicole Constable
731 encompassing others: the magic of modernity in Melanesia (LiPuma)
  Joel Robbins
732 prayer has spoiled everything: possession, power, and identity in an Islamic town of Niger (Masquelier)
  Matthew Engelke
734 car cultures (Miller, ed.)
  Sarah S. Lochlann Jain
735 fragments of the present: searching for modernity in Vietnam’s south (Taylor)
  Ann Marie Leshkowich
737 living narrative: creating lives in everyday storytelling (Ochs and Capps)
  Jennifer A. Dickinson
738 blueprints for a house divided: the constitutional logic of the Yugoslav conflicts (Hayden)
  Paul J. Magnarella
739 men of uncertainty: the social organization of day laborers in contemporary Japan (Gill)
  Michele Gamburd
740 excluded ancestors, inventible traditions: essays toward a more inclusive history of anthropology (Handler, ed.)
  H. Glenn Penny
742 ideologies and technologies of motherhood: race, class, sexuality and nationalism (Ragoné and Twine, eds.)
  Marit Melhuus
743 experimental ethnography: the work of film in the age of video (Russell)
  Peter Biella
744 nation dance: religion, identity, and cultural difference in the Caribbean (Taylor, ed.)
  Christian Krohn-Hansen
746 lost visions and new uncertainties: Sandinista profesionales in northern Nicaragua (Lundgren)
  Florence E. Babb
747 renewing the Maya world: expressive culture in a highland town (Cook)
  Carter Wilson
748 cooperation and community: economy and society in Oaxaca (Cohen)
  Ramona L. Pérez
749 subject to colonialism: African self-fashioning and the colonial library (Desai)
  Herbert S. Lewis
751 salaula: the world of secondhand clothing and Zambia (Hansen)
  Jill Forshee
752 a world of fine difference: the social architecture of a modern Irish village (Peace)
  James G. Flanagan
754 other Chinas: the Yao and the politics of national belonging (Litzinger)
  Susan Hangen
755 postcolonial America (King, ed.)
  Brian Haley
756 remaking a world: violence, social suffering, and recovery (Das, Kleinman, Lock, Ramphele, and Reynolds, eds.)
  Daphne Winland
758 becoming "Japanese": colonial Taiwan and the politics of identity formation (Ching)
  D. J. Hatfield
759 the underneath of things: violence, history, and the everyday in Sierra Leone (Ferme)
  Sónia Silva
761 the lure of the edge: scientific passions, religious beliefs, and the pursuit of UFOs (Denzler)
  Benson Saler
762 Arab Detroit: from margin to mainstream (Abraham and Schyrock, eds.)
  Garbi Schmidt
763 fieldwork dilemmas: anthropologists in postsocialist states (De Soto and Dudwick, eds.)
  Michel Bouchard
765 the haunting fetus: abortion, sexuality and the spirit world in Taiwan (Moskowitz)
  Helen Hardacre
766 the Maya diaspora: Guatemalan roots, new American lives (Loucky and Moors, eds.)
  Liliana R. Goldín
767 embroidering lives: women’s work and skill in the Lucknow embroidery industry (Wilkinson-Weber)
  Coralynn V. Davis
769 Aztecs, Moors, and Christians: festivals of reconquest in Mexico and Spain (Harris)
  Louise M. Burkhart
771 healing in community: medicine, contested terrains, and cultural encounters among the Tuareg (Rasmussen)
  Steven Ferzacca
772 the transnational villagers (Levitt)
  Maxine L. Margolis
774 the nature and function of rituals—fire from heaven (Heinze, ed.)
  Inge Bolin
775 775 transmission difficulties: Franz Boas and Tsimshian Mythology (Maud)
  Judith Berman
777 the elusive embryo: how women and men approach new reproductive technologies (Becker)
  Gail Landsman
778 Muslim Turkistan: Kazak religion and collective memory (Privratsky)
  Hülya Demirdirek
779 claiming sacred ground: pilgrims and politics at Glastonbury and Sedona (Ivakhiv)
  Odd Are Berkaak