AE Vol. 25, no. 3

Contents of Volume 25, Number 3, August 1998

Articles

    More Than an Ethnic Marker: Toraja Art as Identity Negotiator
    Kathleen M. Adams

     In this article I suggest that art can be more than a passive ethnic marker. Focusing on the architecturally based carvings of the Toraja of Indonesia, I argue that artistic forms are sites for the assertion, articulation, and negotiation of various hierarchical identities and relationships. I trace the contested transformation of Toraja architectural symbols of elite authority into generalized icons of Toraja ethnic identity. As I chronicle these shifts I also illustrate how Toraja architectural carvings serve as vehicles for the rearticulation of assorted sets of rank, ethnic, regional, and political relationships. A key objective in this article is to highlight the complicated and often ironic relations between material culture, identity negotiation, and human agency. Drawing on Scott (1985, 1990), I suggest that while art may serve as a weapon of the weak, it can also be a weak weapon. [identity, art, ethnicity, tourism, agency, Indonesia, Toraja]

 A Head for an Eye: Revenge in the Cambodian Genocide
Alexander Laban Hinton

 More than one and one half million Cambodians died from disease, starvation, overwork, and execution under Khmer Rouge rule (1975-79). To help redress the lack of anthropological research on the origins of such large-scale genocides, in this article I explore how the Cambodian cultural model of disproportionate revenge, in combination with Communist Party ideology, provided a cultural template for the extreme violence that took place during this period. [genocide, Cambodia, Khmer Rouge, violence, revenge, cultural models, Marxist ideology]

 Infinity within the Brackets
Annelise Riles

 The ethnographic subjects of this article are UN-sponsored international conferences and their legal documents. Drawing upon fieldwork among Fiji delegates at these conferences, in this article I demonstrate the centrality of matters of form, as distinct from questions of "meaning," in the negotiation of international agreements. A parallel usage of documents and of mats among Fijian negotiators provides a heuristic device for exploring questions of pattern and scale in the aesthetics of negotiation. [documents, institutions, knowledge, aesthetics, law, transnationalism]

 Honor and Stratification in Pohnpei, Micronesia
Elizabeth Keating

 This article is an investigation of honor in a Micronesian society, particularly as it is constructed in language. I argue that honor is a set of practices through which people organize positive embodied attitudes about social hierarchy, according particularly high value to acts of self-depletion. A different notion of the self in the Pacific has implications for ideas about the universality of a personal notion of honor and suggests that the common element in Pohnpeian honor and that described for other societies is the link between honor and inequality or stratification. [honor, honorifics, Pohnpei, Pacific Islands, social stratification, language and culture]

 An Athapaskan Way of Knowing: Chipewyan Ontology
David M. Smith

 The ontology of those Canadian Chipewyan who still actively hunt, fish, and trap is based on the assumption that one must maintain a harmonious communication with nature, especially with animal persons. To this end, emphasis is placed on paying attention to the full complement of holistically interacting senses, giving more attention to the intuitive and affective realms than is typical for Euro-American ontologies. No single sensorium dominates metaphorically; greatest validity is given to firsthand, experiential knowledge attained in waking life or in dreams, with the powerful stories of the elders serving as guides to understanding. Chipewyan thought is monistic--there are no human/nature, mind/body, thought/action, or spirit/matter dualisms. There is a definite cognitive connection among the inseparability of the senses, an implicit monistic philosophy, the understanding that individual can never be separate from society, social egalitarianism, and the belief in the need for maintaining harmonious communication with animal persons. [Chipewyan, ontology, perception, inkonze, monism]

 Tangled Reconciliations: The Anglican Church and the Nisgs'a of British Columbia
John Barker

 In the late 1960s, after decades of neglect, the Anglican Church of Canada rededicated considerable resources to the Nisga'a, a people with whom it had deep missionary ties. In this article I examine the nature of this new relationship and the motivations behind it. The efforts of the contemporary Anglican Church among the Nisga'a are best understood, I argue, as an attempt at reconciliation following a rejection in the national church of earlier assimilationist projects. The Nisga'a reception of the church's outreach, however, was born out of a different process of reconciliation: between indigenous cultural forms and political needs and aspirations, on the one hand, and mission Christianity, which had already developed into a vernacular expression of Christianity in the Nass valley, on the other. I thus explore the politics of religious synthesis in the postmissionary world, a synthesis that occurs simultaneously at local and global levels [northwest coast, Nisga'a, missions, Christianity, land claims, syncretism]

 El Kiosko Budweiser: The Making of a "National" Television Show in Puerto Rico
Arlene Dávila

 Originally devised as a marketing tool for Budweiser beer in Puerto Rico, El Kiosko Budweiser is currently one of the most popular local television shows. An analysis of the production and reception of this show provides the basis for a discussion of its continued popularity and an evaluation of the processes by which mass media products become vehicles for the assertion and definition of contemporary identities. In this article I also question the nature of "national" television in the current transnational context through a discussion of the distinct role played by locally produced commercial programming in the promotion of local artists and shows, and in the imagining of Puerto Rico as a distinct national community. [Puerto Rico, popular culture, national identity, commercial television, advertising]

 Reading the Fools' Mirror: Reconstituting Identity against National and Transnational Political Practices
Hermine G. De Soto

 Previous identity studies have often been presented within a theoretical framework that overemphasizes either the micro or macro context but in which the interaction of both levels is inadequately considered. In this article I examine the conflictual relationship between these levels within a late-modern community in western Germany to show (1) how these national and transnational contexts affect local (micro) existence, and (2) how these effects are turned against national and transnational (macro) economic, political, and policies. I utilize the concept of ritual practice to analyze these unbounded relationships and to explore further how people in a mountainous border village in the Black Forest employ symbols and history in their regional carnival. I argue that these ritualistic practices demonstrate resistance to the national and transnational political and economic forces and the simultaneous reconstitution of local identities. [ritualistic practice, European transnational economic regulations, national policies, western Germany, identity]
 
 
Comments and Reflections
 
 

    The Emperor's New Clothes Removed: A Critique of Besteman's "Violent Politics and the Politics of Violence"
    Bernhard Helander

     Some Comments on Tambiah's Response
    Sasanka Perera

     A Word or Two on "Ethics": A Reply to Arboleda and Murray
    Roger N. Lancaster

     A Mudfight in Same-Sex Research
    Paul Kutsche

     A Response to Kevin Birth
    Daniel A. Segal

     Constructing Identities in Trinidad
    Aisha Khan

     Culture, Secrets, and Ömie History? "Dissemblance" and the Wawaga Valley
    T. R. Barker
     
     

Reviews
    Shifting Contexts: Transformations in Anthropological Knowledge (Locher)
    Marilyn Strathern, ed.

     Counterworks: Managing the Diversity of Knowledge (Romagosa)
    Richard Fardon, ed.

     Things as They Are: New Directions in Phenomenological Anthropology (Weiss)
    Michael Jackson, ed.

     Tense Past: Cultural Essays in Trauma and Memory (Weiss)
    Paul Antze and Michael Lambek, eds.

     Terror and Taboo: The Follies, Fables and Face of Terrorism (Mahmood)
    Joseba Zulaika and William A. Douglass

     Anthropology and Human Movement: The Study of Dances (Wulff)
    Drid Williams, ed.

     Moving Words: Re-Writing Dance (Wulff)
    Gay Morris, ed.

     Body Thoughts (Lamb)
    Andrew J. Strathern

     The Politics of Cultural Performance (Johnson)
    David Parkin, Lionel Caplan, and Humphrey Fischer, eds.

     Being Changed: The Anthropology of Extraordinary Experience (McCall)
    David E. Young and Jean-Guy Goulet, eds.

     Anthropology of Religion: A Handbook (Stewart)
    Stephen D. Glazier, ed.

     Imagined Childhoods: Self and Society in Autobiographical Accounts (Lukose)
    Marianne Gullestad, ed.

     Consumption and Everyday Life (Al-Zubaidi)
    Hugh Mackay, ed.

     Redefining Nature: Ecology, Culture and Domestication (Sayre)
    Roy Ellen and Katsuyoshi Fukui, eds.

     The Anthropology of Tribal and Peasant Pastoral Societies: The Dialectics of Social Cohesion and Fragmentation (Wood)
    Ugo Fabietti and Philip Carl Salzman, eds.

     Human Nature: A Critical Reader (Kaplan)
    Laura Betzig, ed.

     Naven ou le Donner à Voir: Essai D'interprétation de L'action Rituelle (Strathern)
    Michael Houseman and Carlo Severi

     Papuan Borderlands: Huli, Duna, and Ipili Perspectives on the Papua New Guinea Highlands (Stasch)
    Aletta Biersack, ed.

     The Indigenous People of Asia (Locher)
    R. H. Barnes, Andrew Gray, and Benedict Kingsbury, eds.

     Understanding Witchkraft and Sorcery in Southeast Asia (Kapferer)
    C. W. Watson and Roy Ellen, eds.

     The People of the Alas Valley: A Study of an Ethnic Group of Northern Sumatra (Rodgers)
    Akifumi Iwabuchi

     The Ancestral Lords: Gender, Descent, and Spirits in a Northern Thai Village (Mills)
    Michael R. Rhum

     Perspectives on Chinese Society: Anthropological Views from Japan (Wang)
    Suenari Michio, J. S. Eades, and Christina Daniels, eds.

     Women as Subjects: South Asian Histories (Lynch)
    Nita Kumar, ed.

     Art and Life in Bangladesh (Yalman)
    Henry Glassie

     Exploring Confrontation: Sri Lanka--Politics, Culture and History (Guneratne)
    Michael Roberts

     A People of Migrants: Ethnicity, State and Religion in Karachi (Ali)
    Oskar Verkaaik

     Of Revelation and Revolution: The Dialectics of Modernity on a South African Frontier (van Dijk)
    John L. Comaroff and Jean Comaroff

     Savage Systems: Colonialism and Comparative Religion in Southern Africa (Baum)
    David Chidester

     Citizen and Subject: Contemporary Africa and the Legacy of Late Colonialism (Shaw)
    Mahmood Mamdani

     Women of Fire and Spirit: History, Faith and Gender in Roho Religion in Western Kenya (Wood)
    Cynthia Hoehler-Fatton

     Being and Becoming Oromo: Historical and Anthropological Enquiries (Karlstrsm)
    P. T. W. Baxter, Jan Hultin, and Alessandro Triulzi, eds.

     Gender Politics in Sudan: Islamism, Socialism, and the State (Kenyon)
    Sondra Hale

     African Families and the Crisis of Social Change (Smith)
    Thomas S. Weisner, Candice Bradley, and Philip L. Kilbride, eds.

     Playing with Time: Art and Performance in Central Mali (Ottenberg)
    Mary Jo Arnoldi

     Ourselves and Others: The Development of a Greek Macedonian Cultural Identity Since 1912 (Hart)
    Peter Mackridge and Eleni Yannakakis

     Law, Violence and Community in Classical Athens (Lyons)
    David Cohen

     Greeks Bearing Gifts: The Public use of Private Relationships in the Greek World, 435-353 BC (Lyons)
    Lynette G. Mitchell

     Politics and Symbols: The Italian Communist Party and the Fall of Communism (Minicuci)
    David I. Kertzer

     Village Voices: Coexistence and Communication in a Rural Community in Central France (Reed-Danahay)
    Perle Mohl

     Embodied Progress: A Cultural Account of Assisted Conception (Kahn)
    Sarah Franklin

     México Profundo: Reclaiming a Civilization (Levi)
    Guillermo Bonfil Batalla

     History, Power, and Identity: Ethnogenesis in the Americas, 1492-1992 (Rockefeller)
    Jonathan D. Hill, ed.

     Maya Cultural Activism in Guatemala (Hawkins)
    Edward F. Fischer and McKenna Brown, eds.

     Sister Jamaica: A Study of Women, Work, and Households in Kingston (Aymer)
    A. Lynn Bolles

     Exposing Prejudice: Puerto Rican Experiences of Language, Race, and Class (Stinson-Fernandez)
    Bonnie Urciuoli

     The Heartland Chronicles (Niezen)
    Douglas E. Foley

     Los Pastores: History and Performance in the Mexican Shepherd's Play of South Texas (Barriga)
    Richard R. Flores

     Strong Hearts, Wounded Souls: Native American Veterans of the Vietnam War (Wagoner)
    Tom Holm

     Defending the Land: Sovereignty and Forest Life in James Bay Cree Society (Harkin)
    Ronald Niezen

     The Heiltsuks: Dialogues of Culture and History on the Northwest Coast (Buckley)
    Michael E. Harkin